For the ZOA, No Palestinian State

May 21, 2014

Issachar Friedman contends that the choice for Israel lies between “nuanced ‘land for peace” or the “hawkish territorialism and revanchist one-state” ZOA agenda (Your Say, April 24).

The ZOA does not support a one-state agenda, as Friedman would know if he examined our website and publications. Rather, we presently oppose creating a Palestinian state, because neither Mahmoud Abbas’ Palestinian Authority nor Palestinian society in general accept living in peace alongside Israel in a Palestinian state. Abbas and the PA have repeatedly rejected accepting Israel as a Jewish state, demanded that a future Palestinian state be judenrein and refused the idea of ending the conflict even if such a state is created. In case there is any doubt, Abbas reiterated all these points to President Obama just weeks ago.

Friedman claims that pikuach nefesh — protecting and saving lives — has priority over territory. So it does, but his point is irrelevant when experience has shown that ceding territory to unrepentant and unreconstructed Palestinian terrorists has led to a massive increase in the loss of Israeli lives. That is why, for example, the ultra-Orthodox Shas party, which initially cited the imperative of pikuach nefesh in supporting the Oslo Accords, has since admitted it was tragically mistaken to do so.

Creating an irredentist Palestinian Authority state, which can import heavy weaponry, along Israel’s longest border and within mortar range of Ben Gurion Airport and Jerusalem and the coastal plain, which house the vast majority of Israel’s population, drastically endangers Jewish life and statehood.

Morton A. Klein
National President
Zionist Organization of America


COMMENTS
  1. Steve W.

    If Richard Crystal (“Your Say,” May 15) has a beef with Rabbi Wohlberg, he should have a field day with the two May 22 “Your Say” ZOA items.

    Mort Klein – ask Jim Schiller and the BZD about him- speaks with forked tongue.

    First of all, Klein disrespects esteemed talmid chacham Issachar FriedmanN, by (deliberately?) misspelling his last name.

    Secondly, Klein alleges that “The ZOA does not support a one-state agenda.” That is not what his D.C. subaltern Marc Caroff has proclaimed in these very (‘Your Say,’ March 20) pages: “The two-state solution is not the best Zionist option by a long shot;” rather, “negotiation parameters should be based on according the Palestinians some form of ‘autonomy,’ not statehood.”

    Moreover, Caroff has already tipped the ZOA’s real hand – a one-state policy – in his unqualified embrace (July 2, 2013 “Your Say”) of the settler agenda, insisting that it is “time for every mainstream Jewish American organization to show due respect for the pioneering communities in Judea and Samaria.”

    Reply

ADD COMMENTS